ResponsibleSteel, CISA and LESS to test standards compatibility at Chinese steel mills

ResponsibleSteel, CISA and LESS to test standards compatibility at Chinese steel mills

ResponsibleSteel, the China Iron and Steel Association (CISA) and the European Low Emission Steel Standard (LESS) are developing two tools to compare emissions under different standards. The first pilot tests will take place in China, with initial results expected in 2027, ResponsibleSteel said on Nov. 16 at the UN climate conference COP31 in Antalya.

The tools will allow steelmakers to use “the same data set” to assess progress in reducing emissions against thresholds set by different standards. According to ResponsibleSteel, the participating organizations together cover more than 60% of global steel production.

The work builds on agreements reached at COP30 in November 2025. Over the past year, the parties conducted a detailed comparison of ResponsibleSteel’s requirements with China’s C2F Steel standard and LESS. Based on an analysis of common and differing provisions, changes to ResponsibleSteel’s international production standard have been proposed; C2F and LESS are also revising their rules.

A separate ResponsibleSteel greenhouse gas standard and a certification program focused on decarbonization progress are planned for 2027. The organization is also developing a compatible approach to verification so that audit results can be recognized by more than one standard. The initiative aims not to create a single set of global rules, but to enable reliable comparison and mutual recognition of different systems while preserving differences in market and national requirements.

The need for this work is also evident in Fastmarkets’ market assessments: criteria for low-emission steel and its price premiums vary by region. In Northern Europe on Nov. 12, the difference between the price of low-emission flat steel and the hot-rolled coil index was €120–200 ($132–220) per tonne, unchanged week over week. This assessment applies to steel with combined Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions of no more than 0.8 tonnes of CO₂ per tonne of product.

In the US on Nov. 11, the difference between the low-emission steel assessment and the hot-rolled coil price was $0 per short ton, at an emissions threshold of 0.7 tonnes of CO₂ per tonne of steel. This means Fastmarkets’ assessment did not reflect a separate premium for low-emission steel. In Vietnam on Nov. 13, the difference for imported steel relative to the CFR hot-rolled coil price was $110–220 per tonne, unchanged week over week; the applicable Scope 1, 2 and 3 threshold is 1.3 tonnes of CO₂ per tonne of steel. These figures are not directly comparable: they refer to different markets, units of measurement, delivery terms and emissions thresholds.

Production structures also differ. According to the World Steel Association (worldsteel), electric arc furnaces accounted for 71.3% of crude steel production in the US in 2025, 45.8% in the European Union and 10.6% in China. China, the world’s largest steel producer, produced 960.8 million tonnes in 2025; 89.4% was made using the basic oxygen furnace route and 10.6% in electric arc furnaces. ResponsibleSteel said its approach takes into account differences in scrap availability and allows decarbonization to be assessed across different production methods.

Against this backdrop, demand for low-emission flat steel remains weak in Europe. According to Fastmarkets on Nov. 12, market participants said it is difficult to secure a sustained price premium outside trial shipments, individual projects and long-term deals.

Meanwhile, the international Steel Standards Principles initiative said at COP31 that its principles are backed by 67 organizations. Worldsteel continues to compare more than 50 standards and initiatives against 35 criteria to identify areas of alignment, differences and opportunities to bring rules closer together.

Announcing the agreements at COP30, ResponsibleSteel chief executive Annie Heaton said: “ResponsibleSteel is creating a global system that will ensure comparability and form the basis of a global market for low-emission steel.”

Сomments
Add a comment
Сomments (0)
To comment
Войти с Google Войти с Яндекс
Sign in with:
Войти с Google Войти с Яндекс