EU steel imports surged 65% ahead of CBAM launch, then fell 27%

39
0
EU steel imports surged 65% ahead of CBAM launch, then fell 27%

The UK and EU’s carbon border adjustment mechanisms are already reshaping steel trade flows, while significant differences between the two systems could delay mutual exemptions from charges even if the parties agree to link their emissions trading systems. Alwyn Hopkins, EY’s UK and Ireland industry and energy sustainability leader, said this on November 19.

Speaking at a conference hosted by the London-based think tank cbamboo, Hopkins said aligning the UK and EU emissions trading systems would require changes to national legislation, carbon pricing rules and administrative infrastructure. Only after that could companies expect possible exemptions.

The statement came ahead of the UK-EU summit on November 20, where the parties were expected to discuss linking their emissions trading systems. Such an agreement could pave the way for mutual exemptions from the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM).

“I think there are still a lot of hurdles to overcome before we can say that CBAM regimes are comparable,” Hopkins said.

He cited differences in carbon prices, free allocation rules, emissions accounting methodologies and market stability mechanisms. An agreement to link emissions trading systems would therefore not, by itself, lead to an immediate CBAM exemption.

Hopkins cited the EU-Switzerland agreement as a possible example: two separate emissions trading systems operate under mutual recognition of allowances. However, negotiations between the parties began in 2010, and the agreement did not enter into force until 2020 — a sign, Hopkins said, of how complex such arrangements can be.

Meanwhile, CBAM is already affecting steel trade. According to Hopkins, EU imports of iron and steel in December 2025 were 65% above the average for comparable December periods in previous years. In January 2026, the figure was 27% below the average for comparable January periods.

Hopkins suggested that importers may have brought shipments forward ahead of the start of the EU CBAM’s definitive phase on January 1, 2026, to avoid additional emissions costs. However, he warned that other trade measures, including steel safeguards and tariffs, may also have affected the fluctuations.

The effects of carbon border measures go beyond government revenue. In Hopkins’ assessment, changes in supplier choices and trade flows could have a more significant economic impact.

The UK CBAM will take effect on January 1, 2027. Initially, the UK will apply uniform default emissions values regardless of the country of origin, while the EU uses values set separately for different countries. This could result in substantial differences in carbon costs for steel from China, India, Algeria and other countries. The UK plans to switch to country-specific default values in 2029.

The competitiveness of different steelmaking methods could also be affected by the accounting of indirect emissions, particularly emissions from electricity used in electric arc furnaces. Responding to a question from a steelmaker, Hopkins noted that accounting rules could favor some technologies over others, depending on whether indirect emissions are included in the calculation.

According to Hopkins, companies are not yet sufficiently prepared for the introduction of the UK CBAM. This is particularly true of smaller importers and businesses with complex international supply chains.

If the UK and EU fail to reach an agreement, companies moving CBAM-covered goods between the two markets could face duplicate reporting and additional costs. Specific requirements will depend on the goods’ origin and any applicable carbon charge relief.

Hopkins stressed that emissions accounting is becoming a factor in industrial competitiveness, rather than simply a reporting requirement.

“It is now becoming a measure of competitiveness,” he said, adding that companies will have to assess carbon risks across their entire supply chain as carbon regulation and environmental standards expand.

Author: Annalisa Villa

Сomments
Add a comment
Сomments (0)
To comment
Войти с Google Войти с Яндекс
Sign in with:
Войти с Google Войти с Яндекс